Since I write for a real estate publication, I get the, uh, benefit of hearing a lot about property taxes and how people feel about them.
It’s because of that I can feel pretty confident when I say that this may not have been the year to try a 13-cent property tax increase, even if Dallas ISD has one of the lowest rates in the Dallas-Fort Worth area.
Now, my reasons for saying that are completely different than some of the trustees who voted against the tax last night, and which you can read about here, here and here. But for now, let me say this: We cannot fund pre-K expansion and two years of college on eight campuses without some kind of investment. I still absolutely think that every single thing on the original measure was important and worthy of the extra taxation, and if I had been allowed, I would’ve voted for all three measures.
But my reasons for saying this was a bad time are more logistical than philosophical. I kind of had this sinking feeling in the part of my stomach usually reserved for guacamole that the measure wouldn’t pass the second the district revealed that the 13-cent tax could not be broken up ala carte style as originally proposed. But I had also had a lot of input via my inbox and comments on my previous post that led me to believe that people are super peeved about paying more (I know, “duh”). I do think that voters deserved to have the chance to make this decision, and I’m smart enough to know that my busy inbox is no indicator of an election’s success – after all, my inbox was pretty interesting during the bond election, too, and that sucker was passed with 60 percent of the vote.
What’s interesting is that my inbox actually started hurting more after the Dallas County commissioners voted themselves a raise. While I have no science to back this up, the comments became more “my taxes are too much period, yes I know how my total tax bill is calculated, yes I know these are worthy, but dude something’s got to give,” and less, “the school district wastes money anyway” (that last one is not so true, by the way).
But all of this is to say that the hurdle of re-educating everyone on the new tax proposal before November, of overcoming those objections, was an arduous task. And it started last night with the board of trustees – who could not reach the supermajority needed to get the measure on the ballot. There were three trustees already teed up to vote against the proposal. Lew Blackburn’s vote against it, apparently, was because he wasn’t satisfied with some of the answers he was getting from district staff.
My hope is that district staff and amenable trustees don’t let this idea go away but take the year or so to come up with a new plan. I disagree with trustee Lew Blackburn’s (who curiously was forgainst the idea) proposal last night that the election should be in May. I say make it next November, when people have more reasons to vote and turnout is less abysmal. Maybe it’s the Pollyanna in me that hasn’t been beaten into submission yet, but I’d like to think that with more time, the district could regroup and educate voters to even greater success.
Some reaction from last night:
“It’s always rush,” Foreman said. “That’s not the way we should be doing business. We should be good stewards of the taxpayers money.”
— Corbett Smith (@corbettsmithDMN) August 19, 2016
Tonight’s unsuccessful vote on a potential TRE is extremely unfortunate. Voters deserved a chance to help our students. Proud to say I tried
— Miguel Solis (@SolisforDISD) August 19, 2016
Back to @SolisforDISD: For those looking to trim the fat, cut all central office staff, and it still wouldn’t cover what TRE could fund.
— Corbett Smith (@corbettsmithDMN) August 19, 2016
A Tax Ratification Election is the ultimate public vote of confidence for @dallasschools. Voters won’t get that chance and it’s unfortunate.
— Eric Cowan (@ericcowan4DISD) August 19, 2016
@SolisforDISD and voters also deserved a transparent process that was not rushed.
— Omar Jimenez (@OmarUJim) August 19, 2016
Dallas ISD has found a recipe for success; voters deserve a say on whether to fund it @dallasschools @DallasISDMedia https://t.co/DAepbWi5sh
— LEW BLACKBURN (@lewblack) July 29, 2016
