DALTX Real EstateDALTX Real EstateDALTX Real Estate
  • Home
  • Guest Post
  • Agents
  • Contact Us
  • About
  • Advertise With Us
Reading: Commercial Real Estate Exposed: DCAD’s Other Black Hole of Assessed Value Accuracy
Share
Font ResizerAa
DALTX Real EstateDALTX Real Estate
Font ResizerAa
  • Home
  • Guest Post
  • Agents
  • Contact Us
  • About
  • Advertise With Us
  • Home
  • Guest Post
  • Agents
  • Contact Us
  • About
  • Advertise With Us
Follow US
© DALTX. All Rights Reserved.
DALTX Real Estate > Property Taxes > Commercial Real Estate Exposed: DCAD’s Other Black Hole of Assessed Value Accuracy
Property Taxes

Commercial Real Estate Exposed: DCAD’s Other Black Hole of Assessed Value Accuracy

6 Min Read
SHARE
3131-Turtle-Creek-Exterior
Recently sold 3131 Turtle Creek offers glimpse into DCAD’s commercial problem

Whenever property taxes are spoken about, residential usually gets the most ink. The reason is simple. The commercial market offers a fraction of the data available to a residential assessor. In the residential world, similar homes are typically clustered together, placing them in the same valuation realm. There aren’t a lot of crackerboxes on Strait Lane.  However in the commercial world, a four-story building can be next to a skyscraper.

Also, unlike residential, there is no centralized multiple listing service to get a view of commercial properties for sale. If residential is iPads and apps, commercial real estate is the equivalent of a quiet conversation in the back of a darkened, smoke-filled restaurant. It’s just more difficult.

I’ve made the suggestion that DCAD needs to hire appraisers to zoom around town and physically inspect commercial real estate to accurately assess its value. That’s because …

Commercial real estate is wildly undervalued and a few large buildings can escape millions in annual taxes.  Dallas is losing a boatload of tax revenue in the obscured world of commercial real estate and that places a higher burden on residential property owners.

How much are we losing? Here’s one example …

This week it was announced that a 13-story, 140,000-square-foot office building at 3131 Turtle Creek had been sold to the State Teachers Retirement System of Ohio. It’s far from the largest office buildings, but it’s a decent size.  Both The Dallas Morning News and website Chief Investment Officer reported that the sale price was over $350 per square foot.  At $350 per foot, that’s $49 million. Let’s call it $50 million.

DCAD’s 2018 valuation?  $26,545,430.

3131-Turtle-Creek-Exterior

That’s just 53 percent of its lowest (“more than” $350 per foot) selling price. The amount of tax missed from this one building?  $635,209 just this year. Neither article reported on the gaping discrepancy between the sales price and its DCAD assessed valuation.

But it gets juicier.

3131-Turtle-Creek-Exterior
3131 Turtle Creek Assessed Values 1999-2017

The prior owner, Cardinal Capital, purchased the building in 2014 and renovated the building, spending nearly $10 million. At that point, DCAD upped the valuation from $10.4 million to $14.375 million. It’s only in this fourth tax year since acquisition has the building’s assessed value accounted for the $10 million in renovations.

… and juicier …

We all know Dallas real estate, whether commercial or residential, has been on a tear since for several years. So one wonders if DCAD’s 2014-2018 increases factored in the $10 million in renovations at all.

… and juicier still …

Think about “Improvement” on the tables above as the building and the “land” being … well … land.  In the few years Cardinal owned the building, the assessed value increased by $12,170,430, of that, $2.767,430 was land appreciation. The remaining $9,403,000 million was building appreciation.

So for four years, during some of the hottest real estate growth, 3131 Turtle Creek spent $10 million in renovations and in DCAD’s mind the building hasn’t even appreciated the amount of the renovations? How’s that?

By that reckoning, Cardinal Capital is either running a charitable operation or DCAD’s valuation is laughable. I’m going with the latter.

Looking at the land values, recent Turtle Creek residential development deals peg the dirt at $9 million an acre (although since it’s commercial, it’s likely higher). The building’s plot is 1.4 acres, equating to a value of at least $12.6 million. DCAD says $7,606,630.

DCAD-wide, the total assessed value for commercial and industrial property was $92.7 billion in 2016 (latest DCAD data). If commercial real estate in Dallas is as undervalued as this office building, Dallas is only collecting about half the commercial taxes it’s owed.

DCAD needs to do a better job assessing commercial properties to ensure they’re paying their fair share of our ever-increasing tax burden.

Reminder: Protests must be filed by May 15.

3131-Turtle-Creek-Exterior

Remember:  High-rises, HOAs and renovation are my beat. But I also appreciate modern and historical architecture balanced against the YIMBY movement. In 2016 and 2017, the National Association of Real Estate Editors recognized my writing with two Bronze (2016, 2017) and two Silver (2016, 2017) awards.  Have a story to tell or a marriage proposal to make?  Shoot me an email [email protected]. Be sure to look for me on Facebook and Twitter. You won’t find me, but you’re welcome to look.

Texas Voters Approved Propositions 1 and 2, Providing Modest Property Tax Relief
Lynch Legacy Realty Closes Record-Setting Deal For 1,495-Acre Dean Ranch Property
DCAD’s Free Pass on HEB’s Throckmorton Townhouses: Twists, Turns, a Loophole and a Democrat
Title Tip: October is Property Tax Season
How Location Impacts the Value of Commercial Real Estate
TAGGED:Commercial Property TaxesCommercial Real EstateDcadProperty Taxes
Share This Article
Facebook Email Copy Link Print
Previous Article Swiss Avenue Mother’s Day Home Tour Features Architectural Treasures
Next Article Open Floorplan and Sleek Updates Transform this Lake Highlands Home
Popular News
Ashley LaRocca

Ashley LaRocca Joins The Allie Beth Allman URBAN Team

These Tarrant County Homes For Sale Show That Multiple Offers Haven’t Gone Away
Trammell Crow Estate on Market in Highland Park, Listed for $59.4 Million
Find an Exclusive Urban Oasis at this Bluffview Estate on over 2 Acres
Sunny Oak Cliff Cottage-Style Ranch Wows With Upgrades
about us

DaltxRealEstate.com is the largest real estate blog and the only one in North Texas.

Links

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Contact Us
  • Paid Guest Post Submission
  • Real Estate Glossary

Categories

  • Commercial Real Estate
  • Home Inspection
  • East Dallas
  • Monday Morning Millionaire

Get Involved

  • Advertise With Us
  • Write for Us: Submit Guest Post

Find Us on Socials

© DALTX. All Rights Reserved.
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?