DALTX Real EstateDALTX Real EstateDALTX Real Estate
  • Home
  • Guest Post
  • Agents
  • Contact Us
  • About
  • Advertise With Us
Reading: Norm Alston: When it Comes to Preservation, Dallas is a Hormonal Adolescent
Share
Font ResizerAa
DALTX Real EstateDALTX Real Estate
Font ResizerAa
  • Home
  • Guest Post
  • Agents
  • Contact Us
  • About
  • Advertise With Us
  • Home
  • Guest Post
  • Agents
  • Contact Us
  • About
  • Advertise With Us
Follow US
© DALTX. All Rights Reserved.
DALTX Real Estate > Conservation District > Norm Alston: When it Comes to Preservation, Dallas is a Hormonal Adolescent
Conservation District

Norm Alston: When it Comes to Preservation, Dallas is a Hormonal Adolescent

8 Min Read
SHARE
930-valencia-st-dallas-tx-MLS-1-1
One of the stone-embellished Tudor homes in the conservation district of Hollywood Heights. Conservation districts are one of the tools that keep a neighborhood intact.

By Norman Alston, FAIA
Special Contributor

One of the basic tenets in my field of historic preservation is explained by the idea that “a building is a product of its time.” To be more accurate, however, I would expand this idea to say that a building is a creation by people, and the people who cause it to be built are a product of their time. This idea acknowledges that buildings, due to their high utility and very great expense, reflect most clearly our priorities as a society.

While there can be great creativity and personal expression, those elements of our city that are most important to us as a whole are typically reflected clearly through the buildings they create. In other words, these buildings are a clear reflection of our culture.

930-valencia-st-dallas-tx-MLS-1-1
A Craftsman Bungalow in Winnetka Heights, Oak Cliff, a Dallas historic district.

Just one small example of this is found in so many of the houses across the older areas of Dallas. Our 1928 home in East Dallas has a second outside door that opens directly into one of the bedrooms. Virtually every house in our neighborhood has this, as do those in nearby neighborhoods dating back to the 20th Century. This extra door, a reflection of multiple forces and social norms for housing at the time, is unheard of today. It’s more of a cultural expression rather than a technological one, and the need for it has faded into our history.

930-valencia-st-dallas-tx-MLS-1-1
This home on Eighth Street is in an area unprotected by conservation or historic district status. It is within walking distance to the Bishop Arts District and is in the process of being demolished to make way for an apartment block. (Photo by Mimi Perez for Daltxrealestate.com)
W.-8th-Demolition-Fence-1024x768
Eighth Street is fenced for demolition. Photo by Mimi Perez for Candysdirt.com

This concept drives the current debate about demolitions in our established neighborhoods. I have often said that Dallas seems to me to have been an adolescent city throughout most of my life, perhaps too many hormones and not enough life experience to manage them. The forces and priorities that drive our city are changing rapidly, dramatically, and in some cases, painfully.

DSC_0318-edit-candysdirt-1024x638
The Alternatives to Demolition Panel L-R Nathaniel Barrett, Candace Evans, David Spence, Rick Garza, David Preziosi, Andreea Udrea, Paul Carden, and David Noguera. (Photo by Mimi Perez for Daltxrealestate.com)

The Alternatives to Demolition panel that convened on Tuesday evening at Arts Mission Oak Cliff had a fascinating discussion with a diverse panel of skilled experts. These panelists provided a lot of insight into current development forces in Dallas, as well as the historic forces that shaped our city. There were also descriptions of many tools that are currently available to us as we deal with the needs driving modern development and redevelopment, as well as consideration of tools still needed.

However, what ties this together, and what seems to serve as the source of the pain I referenced, is culture. In historic preservation, we have long advocated for developing a new culture of preservation for our community.

W.-8th-Demolition-Fence-1024x768DSC_0318-edit-candysdirt-1024x638
The Hal Thomson designed historic 3800 Beverly in Highland Park will soon be replaced. (Photo on right by Mimi Perez for Daltxrealestate.com.)


Instead of the default question of “Why preserve?” we should be asking “Why not preserve?”

It has often been expressed that Dallas is too young to have enough history to develop a cultural depth that is uniquely Dallas and worthy of preservation. It is often said that what history we had has already been lost and that all value lies in our future.

Instead, we find ourselves in a new place. Until recently, we have been focused nationally on “new.” I often speak about how our design and construction industry has been geared toward new construction. Only in the past decade have technologies and attitudes begun to realize that we have inherited a great legacy city and that it has qualities and character that continue to be valuable, and people have started to fight to keep them.

W.-8th-Demolition-Fence-1024x768
Tenth Street, Oak Cliff

In 2016, in response to a series of concerns advanced by the architectural community, the Dallas Chapter of the American Institute of Architects spent months considering these same issues. The result was a policy position known as the Policy Statement on Local Architectural Heritage In it, concern and consideration were extended well beyond the built environment. It recognized that neighborhoods and communities are far more than just the buildings but also include a broad and complex combination of qualities developed over time that give the neighborhood its own identity and that this identity is often valuable and worth keeping. It advocates for recognizing such qualities and their inclusion in redevelopment plans.

930-valencia-st-dallas-tx-MLS-1-1
The changing face of Oak Cliff. (Photo by Mimi Perez for Daltxrealestate.com)

It is this crisis of culture that baffles us today. From the demolition of homes in the Park Cities to the loss of Ebby Halliday’s house to the replacement of homes in neighborhoods across our city to the preservation and redevelopment of the Bottoms and Tenth Street, we find ourselves developing a new culture that considers qualities we hoped for, but perhaps didn’t realize that we already had. And we’re doing so on the fly.

930-valencia-st-dallas-tx-MLS-1-1
A new apartment complex going up next to a single-family home in Oak Cliff. (Photo by Mimi Perez for Daltxrealestate.com)
DSC_0318-edit-candysdirt-1024x638
The new face of Oak Cliff? (Photo by Mimi Perez for Daltxrealestate.com)

The path forward is the responsibility of us all. Let us consider and demand better urban planning from everyone, including ourselves. Let us use the tools available to us from the City of Dallas, and let’s have more of them, but let’s relieve the city from the burden of inspiration and vision for our city. That’s our job.

Let us look to and engage with one another to decide what kind of city we want. Let’s engage in the process, like the ForwardDallas! update and the Atlas Metalworks debate.

Let’s keep talking to our neighbors.

David R. Williams Historic Texas Ranch Can be Yours if You’re Smart!
Preservation Dallas Partners on The Greenland Hills Centennial Home Tour
Ronald Siebler Is Preservation ‘Man of the Hour,’ Recipient of Prestigious Award
Loving a Peak’s Suburban Addition Prairie Back to Life
Lakewood Theater Wins Big Again In Preservation Achievement Awards
TAGGED:Adaptive Reusealternatives to demolitionArts Mission Oak CliffHistoric districtHistoric PreservationNorman Alston Architecturepreservation
Share This Article
Facebook Email Copy Link Print
Previous Article Fort Worth Agent Sues KWRI, Accuses Former CEO John Davis, Who She Once Dated, of Sexual Misconduct
Next Article The Cliff Freeman Group Invites You to Think Like a Billionaire
Popular News
Oak Cliff

Ready For a 2023 With Income Potential? Add a Cute Oak Cliff Duplex to Your Real Estate Portfolio

Enjoy Arts, Crafts, And Classic Automobiles With The Junius Heights Historic Home Tour Nov. 4
Anthony Graham: Moving Back to the Mothership, SOUTH of LBJ
The Most Expensive (and Largest) High Rise Homes on Turtle Creek, Ltd Edition 2505, Officially for Sale Saturday
Angie Barrett’s One Arts Condo Sells to Former Denton Mayor, Now Legal Battles Going On
about us

DaltxRealEstate.com is the largest real estate blog and the only one in North Texas.

Links

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Contact Us
  • Paid Guest Post Submission

Categories

  • Wednesday WTF
  • East Dallas
  • Monday Morning Millionaire
  • Upon Closer Inspection

Get Involved

  • Advertise With Us
  • Write for Us: Submit Guest Post

Find Us on Socials

© DALTX. All Rights Reserved.
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?