Now Dallas Police have confirmed that the body in the backyard is indeed Shumway, and have issued a warrant for the arrest of Christopher Brian Colbert, the 43-year-old who posed as Shumway to Realtors and Chicago Title Company in order to sell Shumway’s home last year.
The home, which Colbert sold for $130,000, was later flipped several times until it was purchased by the investor who discovered the body during renovations.
Colbert contacted a broker in May for an evaluation of Shumway’s house, according to his arrest warrant. He introduced himself as Shumway and signed a contract with the broker, agreeing to sell the house for $145,000, the warrant states.
Three days after the meeting, Colbert got in touch with the broker using Shumway’s email account and said he wanted to sell quickly, according to the warrant. The asking price was dropped to $130,000.
Christopher Brian Colbert
On June 22, when the escrow officer closing the sale asked Colbert for identification, he reportedly told her didn’t have his driver’s license with him but would fax it later. Investigators said he signed the closing documents, “Ronald D. Shumway.”
The next day, police said, Colbert faxed over a doctored version of Shumway’s license, one that had Colbert’s photo on it.
“Thanks! Nice to meet you,” he wrote in the fax, according to police.
The title company then wired the proceeds of the home sale, about $110,000, to a bank account that belonged to Shumway and his late mother. Police believe Colbert used Shumway’s debit card to make withdrawals from the account.
There are some big, glaring problems here: Why did the title company allow the transaction to go forward without the proper identification? Is it ever OK for a homeowner to fax a copy of their ID instead of presenting it for inspection? Who’s liable since the sale is fraudulent? And who actually owns the home?
Police sources told NBC5 someone forged Shumway’s signature in late June on a legal document authorizing the sale of his house in the 700 block of North Winnetka Avenue.
Tax records show the home was bought by an investment company in June, then sold to a real estate investment company in August.
Shumway’s signature appears on the June 22 deed authorizing the sale, almost two months after he was last seen. The deed was notarized by a licensed notary with an office in North Dallas, NBC5 reported.
The notary first told NBC5 she didn’t recall meeting Shumway but later said she had no comment.
We’ve reached out to a few title experts to get the facts. Stay tuned.
